Discover why it's important to create high-quality content with Don Draper. From understanding its key characteristics to what separates it from low-quality.

When everyone faces the same problem, everyone gets given an equal opportunity.

Today, that challenge is content saturation.

With AI-powered content tools now available to practically anyone, it’s never been easier or faster to produce marketing content. As a result, the internet has become completely saturated with mediocrity.

But as Mad Men’s leading man, Don Draper demonstrated in the pilot episode of the award-winning series (when it seemed all creativity and inspiration had forsaken him), what first appears as a limitation can be flipped into an opportunity.

“This is the greatest advertising opportunity since the invention of cereal!”

- Donald Draper, Mad Men

That same principle applies to marketing today. As generic, AI-generated content becomes increasingly commonplace, truly high-quality content becomes increasingly valuable.

Therefore, to rise above the swamp of low-quality, AI-slop, brands have just one choice.

To raise the bar.  

Because when everyone can create content, quality becomes the ultimate differentiator.

What makes high-quality content?

We can define high-quality content in marketing as content that is accurate, engaging, and original. It directly serves the needs of the audience and more. Search for an answer, and you get the correct response. Search for entertainment? You're hooked from the opening line.

In short, high-quality content gives people what they need and then goes one step further. It doesn't just meet expectations, it exceeds them.

That distinction matters now, more than ever.

The rise of AI has dramatically lowered the barrier to entry for content creation. Why pay a professional when you can do it yourself? Ideas can be turned into blogs, captions, and videos in a matter of minutes.

But while AI has made content creation faster, it hasn't automatically made content better.

Speed is no longer a competitive advantage. Quality is what separates the Don Drapers of this world from the copycats.

Ignoring his personal flaws, no one can deny his brilliance as an advertising creative. His genius wasn’t because he could produce more content than anyone else. He was invaluable because he could find insight nobody else had seen.

When ‘Lucky Strike’ could no longer promote its products as healthy, its marketing message stalled, alongside the entire industry.

But what Don made ‘Lucky Strike’ realise was they could say anything they wanted…

“It’s toasted.”

“But everyone else’s cigarettes are toasted.”  

“No. Everyone else’s cigarettes are poisonous.”

The product hadn't changed, the process wasn’t unique, nor was the production any different to their competitors.

Only the insight was.

Why is it important to create high-quality content?

The powers that decide what content gets on our screens are increasingly aligned on the same principle.

Content is now common. Quality is King.

Google has improved its vetting process for high-quality content with EEAT guidelines (Experience, expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness).

High-quality content demonstrates expertise. It builds trust. It answers questions thoroughly, provides genuine insight, and offers a perspective that can't simply be copied and pasted from a random website.  

By following an EEAT framework, brands can convince Google that their content is worthy of display in its SERPs, with each element playing a distinct role:

- Experience demonstrates that you've been there and done it. Your insights are grounded in real-world knowledge rather than theory alone, supported by examples, evidence, and first-hand understanding.

- Expertise shows a deep understanding of a subject via relevant experience. It's the knowledge and skill that allows you to explain complex topics clearly, accurately, and confidently.

- Authoritativeness is the reputation you build when others recognise that expertise. It reflects the respect, recognition, and credibility you've earned within your industry.

- Trustworthiness is the outcome of consistently demonstrating all three. It reassures audiences that your content is accurate, reliable, and created with their interests in mind.

But high-quality content extends far beyond SEO. After all, Google isn't the only audience you're trying to impress. The ultimate measure of quality isn't whether a search engine ranks your content highly; it's whether a real person finds it valuable.

And sometimes, the easiest way to understand what quality looks like is to examine its opposite.

What is low-quality content?

Low-quality content can be defined as lacking accuracy, originality, and overall user value. It fails to fulfil its purpose and wastes your time.

You can define low-quality content with the following characteristics:

• Failing to answer the query or offering any real substance.
• Lacking EEAT.
• Duplicating other material.
• Misleading headlines (Clickbaiting).
• Trend chasing.
• Keyword stuffing.
• Overall, poor UX (User experience).

So, where does AI come into all this?

Is AI content low-quality?

AI appears confident, but its output is generic and unoriginal, offering volume over value. Despite the boom, it’s catching on, with Gartner Data revealing 49% of people believe AI has made content quality worse.

The reason for this is systematic. AI is designed to predict the most plausible solution, not create original insight or offer meaning.

And we all know, the last thing the internet needs is more noise.

This is not to say that AI can’t be prompted to create high-quality content. But again, that relies on human input to define good quality from bad.

So, how do we do that?

How to define quality content

We can’t determine quality by a single characteristic. It's the result of countless skills, decisions, and details coming together to create something greater than the sum of its parts.

To explore this idea further, let's reunite with Don and rewind to 1960s Manhattan.

After securing a new client for Sterling Cooper, you, Don, and Roger head to a jazz bar to celebrate.

Don orders an Old Fashioned, Roger a Gibson, and you a Rob Roy. From the cocktails to the company and the atmosphere, there's an unmistakable sense of class and confidence.

Everything feels smooth. Refined. Effortless.

Much like high-quality content:

High-quality content is original

A jazz quartet is performing on stage.

They're not being paid because they can play any old tune. They're here because any mention of mediocrity is an insult to their artistry. Their style can't be replicated, and they know any flat, uninspired performance will see them replaced tomorrow night.

Waiting for your Rob Roy to arrive, you're captivated. You've never heard anything like it before in your life. Every note commands attention. Every melody makes you move in your seat. Every solo tells a story. By the end of the song, you're half-convinced to abandon advertising altogether and learn the saxophone.

Great content has the same effect.

It doesn't recycle the same ideas everyone else is publishing. It offers a fresh perspective, a unique insight, or a memorable way of communicating something familiar.

It gives audiences a reason to stop scrolling and pay attention.

High-quality content takes time

You ordered your drinks five minutes ago, and they still haven’t arrived. Why? Because making an Old Fashioned properly requires at least five minutes of stirring two ice cubes (one after the other) to infuse the whisky, sugar and bitters.

Finally, it arrives, and you take that first sip. Sure, you could’ve had your drinks five minutes before, but they would’ve tasted pretty lousy. The whiskey would’ve been far too overpowering with the sugar granules left sitting at the bottom of the glass.

Like high-quality content, research, editing, and refining all take time. The stuff that resonates most with audiences is usually the content that somebody cared enough to improve.

High-quality content is knowledge

As the evening unfolds, you realise something else.

The people here don't just have access to quality, they understand it.

From the cocktails to the music and conversation (you’ve missed your train home already without even realising), everyone recognises what makes something good.

It’s the reason they’re here, and the reason you’re here too.

AI can generate something that looks high-quality. It can follow patterns, mimic expertise, and produce at scale. But quality isn't just about appearance. It's about understanding.

Truly knowing whether something is accurate, useful, original, or insightful requires human knowledge.

And this quality can’t simply be automated into existence.

So, why is it important to create high-quality content?

Because without it, we all just end up the same.

And isn’t the entire point of marketing, of content, of creativity itself, to be anything other than that?

Create High-Quality Content with Content Chef

Reading this blog should say enough about why we believe high-quality content matters and why your business needs it now more than ever.

At Content Chef, we’re not happy with anything mediocre. We believe every brand has a unique story to tell that only you can share with the world.

To understand more about how we can create high-quality content for your business, get in touch today.

Written by Archie Edwards

‍

‍